Saugatuck, Michigan

Sarah and I recently visited Saugatuck, Michigan while in the area for my brother's wedding. Saugatuck is a very small, picturesque town on the shores of Lake Michigan which is known for its community of artists. It reminded us a lot of Key West.

For lunch we visited Pumpernickels. We started off by splitting a cinnamon roll, which, while not a typical appetizer option, looked too good to pass up. It was unbelievably good, with so much cinnamon flavor that it almost tasted spicy (but it was plenty sweet as well). It was probably the best cinnamon roll I've ever had.
For sandwiches Sarah ordered the tuna salad on pumpernickel and I had a turkey, bacon and Swiss on cracked wheat. The sandwiches were fairly generously portioned and very fresh, but a bit heavier on the bread than I generally like. Sarah loves bread, so she was fine with the ratio. Jonathan had a peanut butter and jelly. They were really generous with the fillings, and his was actually really yummy.



For dessert we headed over to Kilwin's. There are actually two locations on the same street, which is pretty weird for a town of around 1,000 people. We saw them making fudge, which of course involved loads of sugar. On the bags of sugar was written "15 calories per teaspoon" in huge letters. The fudge looked to be around 90% sugar, and I'm guessing very few people consider 1-2 teaspoons of fudge a single serving.

Jonathan ordered a milk chocolate marshmallow, which was very good. The marshmallows were clearly homemade and had a density and strong vanilla flavor that you'll never find in a "jet puffed" marshmallow. Sarah had a dark chocolate peanut butter cup, which she said was the best peanut butter cup she's ever had (and she's definitely a connoisseur). I had a chocolate covered pretzel rod, which I very much enjoyed. Their chocolate is very flavorful and just sweet enough to satisfy a sugar craving without being cloying. I grew up in the town where the first Kilwin's opened (I think), but you can now find them all over the country.
We'd definitely recommend both Pumpernickels and Kilwin's if you're ever in the area. And it's definitely a good region to visit, considering the lakefront cottages and general sense of escaping from civilization.
by Ben at5:10 PM under bakery, kid approved, michigan, restaurant review, travel

